Drug and Device Law, a definitive source for commentary on legal matters pertaining to drug and device product liability cases, recently recognized a Harris Beach Murtha case as one of the 10 best decisions in the field in 2025.
In a column titled “Running the Table – The Ten Best Prescription Drug/Medical Device Decisions of 2025,” author James Beck wrote the Silverstein v. CoolSculpting Zeltiq Aesthetics, Inc., case “is a relatively rare published state-court opinion flatly rejecting an increasingly common, and thoroughly obnoxious, plaintiff argument – that product liability defendants have duties to warn about the risk of products made by others.”
The case concerned a product made by Zeltiq that a doctor successfully used to treat a patient. However, when the patient was later treated with ice packs (made by another manufacturer) that blistered the skin, the patient filed a lawsuit maintaining that Zeltiq had a duty to warn that harm could be caused when ice packs were used in that manner. The Court ruled that Zeltiq has no such duty, because the facts did not fit the very narrow exception under which a manufacturer’s duty to warn may extend to risks associated with products made by third parties.
This is at least the second time the case has been publicly recognized. In March, author Stephen McConnell, wrote a blog post entitled “New York Appellate Court Reverses Denial of Summary Judgement and Holds No Duty to Warn of Someone Else’s Product,” declaring the favorable decision as an example of “the very best form of authority” supporting strict limitations on a medical device manufacturer’s duty to warn of risks associated with another manufacturer’s product. He also noted that “Silverstein sits at the top of this hierarchy” of case law authority, and likely will be readily cited by similarly situated defendants when arguing for a grant of summary judgment dismissal.
The Harris Beach Murtha team on the case included partners Kelly Jones Howell, leader of the firm’s Medical & Life Sciences Industry Team; Brian Ginsberg, leader of the firm’s Appellate Practice Group, who led the appellate briefing and presented oral argument in the appeal; and Appellate Practice Group member Erin Peradotto. They were ably assisted by Cynthia Cook Robertson.