Harris Beach Murtha’s Brian D. Ginsberg recently spoke with the New York Law Journal about a new rule from New York’s top court that limits how amicus briefs may address legislative intent.
The New York Court of Appeals announced that friend-of-the-court briefs on cases about legislative intent and statutes may no longer present lawmakers’ views expressed outside of the publicly available contemporaneous legislative history, limiting writers to citation of acts that were part of the official record. The new rule is set to take effect Dec. 10.
Calling Brian a top appellate attorney, the NYLJ story noted he doesn’t recall ever seeing a provision like this anywhere in the United States.
“The Court of Appeals and other appellate courts across the country have rules concerning the procedures for amicus filings, including provisions on timing, whether the parties must consent to the filing, whether leave of court is required, and similar issues,” said Ginsberg, a former assistant solicitor general.
“But I do not recall ever seeing a provision like this new one, which restricts the substance of what potential amici may argue on a particular subject, here the subject of statutory construction and legislative intent,” Ginsberg said.
Brian, leader of the firm’s Appellate Practice Group, said he does not expect the restriction on “publicly available” sources to prove controversial because sources that are not publicly available constitute new facts, which generally are not appropriate to insert into an appeal.
Read more about Brian’s opinion on the new rule. (Subscription may be required.)