In their latest column for Massachusetts Auto Dealer Magazine, three Harris Beach Murtha attorneys highlight manufacturers targeting state franchise laws as anticompetitive and harmful to consumer, but note franchises were fighting back.
Attorneys Thomas S. Vangel, James F. Radke and Lindsey M. McComber, members of Harris Beach Murtha’s Automotive and Vehicle Dealerships Industry Team, wrote auto manufacturers recently responded to a request from the U.S. Department of Justice’s Anticompetitive Regulations Task Force to identify “state and federal laws and regulations that undermine free market competition and harm consumers, workers, and businesses.”
They wrote manufacturers asked the Justice Department to scrutinize and repeal state law protections for franchised auto dealers, “including (1) state laws restricting the establishment of new motor vehicle dealerships in relevant market areas of existing same line make dealers and (2) state laws setting minimum levels of compensation to dealers for warranty service,” the attorneys wrote.
“Particularly, the Alliance argued that state statutory provisions protecting the ‘relevant market area’ of existing deal¬ers and allowing for an automatic stay of a proposed new dealership during any legal process, as provided in some state franchise laws, allows dealers to “protect themselves from increased competition and delay the establishment of a new dealership…without regard to the effects on consumers.’ ”
The attorneys did not mince words, writing: “These comments attack at the heart of the protections afforded to Massachusetts dealers under Chapter 93B. Chapter 93B significantly restricts manufacturers from entering into a franchise agreement with a motor vehicle dealer that would operate within the relevant market area (“RMA”) of an existing same line make dealer. Years ago the MSADA fought hard to establish RMA mileage definitions that eliminate the need for expensive experts and protracted legal process to determine the RMA of individual dealers.”
They then noted the National Automobile Dealers Association (NADA) sent a strongly worded response to the Department of Justice, claiming manufacturers allegations go beyond “policy disagreements and “constitute[] a broadside attack on our members and erodes trust between dealers and manufacturers.” The NADA noted that the Alliance’s comments “are nothing short of an invocation of federal authority to attack the franchise system writ (sic) large.”
Harris Beach Murtha attorneys promised to “monitor closely the actions of the Task Force and the Alliance over the coming months to vigilantly protect our franchise system.”
Read the full article for more detail.