skip to main content
Harris Beach Murtha Attorneys at Law
Capabilities
People
main menu
Harris Beach Murtha Attorneys at Law
  • Capabilities
  • People
  • Capabilities
  • People
About
About
Inclusion and Engagement
Social Impact
Lateral Opportunities
About
Inclusion and Engagement
Social Impact
Lateral Opportunities
Resources
Insights
News
Events
Insights
News
Events
Careers
Contact
Offices
Wills, Trusts & Estates Blog
October 28, 2026

Surrogate Case Calls to Question Whether Witnesses to Wills Must be 18

Authors and Contacts

Meaghan T. Feenan (Lambert)

Facebook
(Twitter)
LinkedIn
Email
Copy Page Link

The Surrogate’s Court in Nassau County recently issued a decision that may lead to a change in New York’s procedure for the execution and attestation of wills. In the Matter of Winslow, court discussion noted that EPTL 3-2.1 “surprisingly” does not require an attesting witness to a will execution to be at least 18 years of age, even though EPTL 3-1.1 requires a testator be at least 18 years of age.

One of the two witnesses to the will in the Winslow matter was a minor at the time of witnessing. Petitioners asked the court to dispense with the testimony of the witness because she was a minor at the time. The court granted the petition on July 7, 2026, but not before discussion about the inconsistency in the state’s procedure for executing and attesting wills.

Case Background

In the probate proceeding for the will of Gloria M. Winslow, the petitioners, Lorenzo Ricardo Winslow (Lorenzo) and Gloria M. Winslow (Gloria), offered for probate a purported will dated February 24, 2017, and asked that letters testamentary be issued to them. The decedent died on December 21, 2023, and was survived by her four children, Lorenzo, Gloria, Charles Willie Winslow II and Charles Linwood Winslow II.

The will was witnessed by the decedent’s neighbor and her granddaughter, Azia Rogers. Rogers had submitted an affidavit stating that, at the time she witnessed the will, she was only 16 years old. She was also a beneficiary of the will, which bequeathed five sets of salt and pepper shakers to each of the decedent’s grandchildren who survived her.

The petitioners asked the court to dispense with the testimony of Azia given she was a minor at the time she acted as a subscribing witness to the will. The court considered that while EPTL 3-1.1 requires a person to be 18 years or older to dispose of real and personal property, EPTL 3-2.1(a)(2) “surprisingly” holds no such age requirement for attesting witnesses of the will.

Citing a 1935 decision in the Matter of Tannenbaum, the court ultimately found the infancy of a subscribing witness, by itself, is not sufficient to invalidate a will even though courts consider minors as persons under a disability (SCPA 103[40]) for whom a guardian ad litem would be appointed. Based on this reasoning and Rogers’ affidavit, the court granted the petition, concluding Rogers understood the obligation to act as a witness at the time she witnessed the will.

Additionally, the court briefly discussed that Rogers may have forfeited her share of the estate ( five sets of the decedent’s coveted salt and pepper shakers), given EPTL 3-3.2 provides that any attesting witness to a will to whom a beneficial disposition is made forfeit his or her bequest, unless there are at least two other attesting witnesses to the will who have no beneficial disposition. However, the court opted to leave the forfeiture determination for a subsequent accounting proceeding.

Why This Matters

This decision brings into question whether it is necessary to amend EPTL 3-2.1 to require witnesses to be 18 years or older to align with EPTL 3-1.1, which mandates that a testator be at least 18 years of age. Adding an age requirement would align EPTL 3-2.1 with SCPA 103[40], which includes an infant in the definition of a person with a disability for whom a guardian ad litem would be appointed.

Suprisingly, New York is not alone in not setting a minimum age for witnesses to wills. Forty three states and the District of Columbia impose no statutory age at all, simply requiring the witness to be “competent,” “generally competent” or “credible.” This includes all northeastern states, such as New Jersey, Connecticut, Massachusetts and Rhode Island.

Arkansas, Idaho and Ohio require a witness to be a legal adult, 18 years or older. Georgia and Texas require witnesses to be at least age 14; Iowa and Louisiana require at least age 16.

Harris Beach Murtha’s Trusts and Estates Practice Group will monitor to see if the Winslow court discussion prompts New York to remove itself from the list of states without a minimum age for witnesses and will report new developments.

Law clerk Kathryn T. Benedetti contributed to this report.

If you need assistance with a will, trust or other estate matter, please reach out to attorney Meaghan T. Feenan at (518) 701-2742 and mfeenan@harrisbeachmurtha.com or the Harris Beach Murtha attorney with whom you most frequently work.

This alert is not a substitute for advice of counsel on specific legal issues.

Harris Beach Murtha’s lawyers and consultants practice from offices throughout Connecticut in Bantam, Hartford, New Haven and Stamford; New York State in Albany, Binghamton, Buffalo, Ithaca, New York City, Niagara Falls, Rochester, Saratoga Springs, Syracuse, Long Island and White Plains; as well as in Boston, Massachusetts; Providence, Rhode Island; and Newark, New Jersey.

Authors and Contacts

Meaghan Feenan

Meaghan T. Feenan (Lambert)

Member

Related Legal Practices

Trusts and Estates
Facebook
(Twitter)
LinkedIn
Email
Copy Page Link

Contact Us

Harris Beach Murtha Attorneys at Law
  • Contact
  • Offices
  • Privacy Policy
  • Legal Disclaimer
  • Site Map
  • Contact
  • Offices
  • Privacy Policy
  • Legal Disclaimer
  • Site Map
Payment Portal
X-twitter Facebook Linkedin Instagram
Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. © 2026 Harris Beach Murtha Cullina PLLC
TRUSTe
Harris Beach Murtha Attorneys at Law
Back to Top

Insights

Surrogate Case Calls to Question Whether Witnesses to Wills Must be 18

Capabilities
People
Harris Beach Murtha Attorneys at Law
Wills, Trusts & Estates Blog
October 28, 2026

Surrogate Case Calls to Question Whether Witnesses to Wills Must be 18

Insight

The Surrogate's Court in Nassau County recently issued a decision that may lead to a change in New York’s procedure for the execution and attestation of wills. In the Matter of Winslow, court discussion noted that EPTL 3-2.1 “surprisingly” does not require an attesting witness to a will execution to be at least 18 years of age, even though EPTL 3-1.1 requires a testator be at least 18 years of age.

One of the two witnesses to the will in the Winslow matter was a minor at the time of witnessing. Petitioners asked the court to dispense with the testimony of the witness because she was a minor at the time. The court granted the petition on July 7, 2026, but not before discussion about the inconsistency in the state’s procedure for executing and attesting wills.

Case Background

In the probate proceeding for the will of Gloria M. Winslow, the petitioners, Lorenzo Ricardo Winslow (Lorenzo) and Gloria M. Winslow (Gloria), offered for probate a purported will dated February 24, 2017, and asked that letters testamentary be issued to them. The decedent died on December 21, 2023, and was survived by her four children, Lorenzo, Gloria, Charles Willie Winslow II and Charles Linwood Winslow II.

The will was witnessed by the decedent's neighbor and her granddaughter, Azia Rogers. Rogers had submitted an affidavit stating that, at the time she witnessed the will, she was only 16 years old. She was also a beneficiary of the will, which bequeathed five sets of salt and pepper shakers to each of the decedent's grandchildren who survived her.

The petitioners asked the court to dispense with the testimony of Azia given she was a minor at the time she acted as a subscribing witness to the will. The court considered that while EPTL 3-1.1 requires a person to be 18 years or older to dispose of real and personal property, EPTL 3-2.1(a)(2) “surprisingly” holds no such age requirement for attesting witnesses of the will.

Citing a 1935 decision in the Matter of Tannenbaum, the court ultimately found the infancy of a subscribing witness, by itself, is not sufficient to invalidate a will even though courts consider minors as persons under a disability (SCPA 103[40]) for whom a guardian ad litem would be appointed. Based on this reasoning and Rogers’ affidavit, the court granted the petition, concluding Rogers understood the obligation to act as a witness at the time she witnessed the will.

Additionally, the court briefly discussed that Rogers may have forfeited her share of the estate ( five sets of the decedent's coveted salt and pepper shakers), given EPTL 3-3.2 provides that any attesting witness to a will to whom a beneficial disposition is made forfeit his or her bequest, unless there are at least two other attesting witnesses to the will who have no beneficial disposition. However, the court opted to leave the forfeiture determination for a subsequent accounting proceeding.

Why This Matters

This decision brings into question whether it is necessary to amend EPTL 3-2.1 to require witnesses to be 18 years or older to align with EPTL 3-1.1, which mandates that a testator be at least 18 years of age. Adding an age requirement would align EPTL 3-2.1 with SCPA 103[40], which includes an infant in the definition of a person with a disability for whom a guardian ad litem would be appointed.

Suprisingly, New York is not alone in not setting a minimum age for witnesses to wills. Forty three states and the District of Columbia impose no statutory age at all, simply requiring the witness to be “competent,” “generally competent” or “credible.” This includes all northeastern states, such as New Jersey, Connecticut, Massachusetts and Rhode Island.

Arkansas, Idaho and Ohio require a witness to be a legal adult, 18 years or older. Georgia and Texas require witnesses to be at least age 14; Iowa and Louisiana require at least age 16.

Harris Beach Murtha’s Trusts and Estates Practice Group will monitor to see if the Winslow court discussion prompts New York to remove itself from the list of states without a minimum age for witnesses and will report new developments.

Law clerk Kathryn T. Benedetti contributed to this report.

If you need assistance with a will, trust or other estate matter, please reach out to attorney Meaghan T. Feenan at (518) 701-2742 and mfeenan@harrisbeachmurtha.com or the Harris Beach Murtha attorney with whom you most frequently work.

This alert is not a substitute for advice of counsel on specific legal issues.

Harris Beach Murtha’s lawyers and consultants practice from offices throughout Connecticut in Bantam, Hartford, New Haven and Stamford; New York State in Albany, Binghamton, Buffalo, Ithaca, New York City, Niagara Falls, Rochester, Saratoga Springs, Syracuse, Long Island and White Plains; as well as in Boston, Massachusetts; Providence, Rhode Island; and Newark, New Jersey.

Authors

Meaghan T. Feenan (Lambert)

Member
(518) 701-2742
mfeenan@harrisbeachmurtha.com
Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. © 2026 Harris Beach Murtha Cullina PLLC
Content current as of November 8, 2026 2:27 am