skip to main content
Harris Beach Murtha Attorneys at Law
Capabilities
People
main menu
Harris Beach Murtha Attorneys at Law
  • Capabilities
  • People
  • Capabilities
  • People
About
About
Inclusion and Engagement
Social Impact
Lateral Opportunities
About
Inclusion and Engagement
Social Impact
Lateral Opportunities
Resources
Insights
News
Events
Insights
News
Events
Careers
Contact
Offices
Legal Alert
April 1, 2022

No Surprises Act Shouldn’t Stun Physicians in New York State

Authors and Contacts

Roy W. Breitenbach

Facebook
(Twitter)
LinkedIn
Email
Copy Page Link

This week, Crain’s Health Pulse highlighted a lawsuit that I and my colleagues Dan Hallak and Jack Martins commenced earlier this week. We filed the lawsuit on behalf of 18 physician practices and four Empire Plan enrollees in the Supreme Court, Albany County, contending that the New York State Health Insurance program has attempted to sidestep the state’s surprise-billing law, drastically reducing payments for out-of-network services more than 80 percent.

The federal No Surprises Act (NSA) took effect on January 1, 2022 – governing how managed care companies reimburse out-of-network providers and how disputes between health plans and out-of-network providers are resolved. This law is designed to manage patients’ costs for emergency services or health care they receive at an in-network facility, from out-of-network doctors. Federal and state laws have established different benchmarks for determining a “reasonable amount” when insurers and physicians disagree. In this case, the health plan has opted to funnel these surprise-billing disputes through the federal government’s adjudication system, instead of the process outlined in New York state’s surprise billing law.

This lawsuit underscores the importance of understanding key issues. How does the NSA work within the existing New York Surprise Bill Law, and what is the impact on health practices that are chiefly out-of-network, such as anesthesiology, pathology and surgical care? How can practices best serve patients while protecting their business? Join us on Wednesday for our latest webinar on the Federal NSA.

Authors and Contacts

Partner Roy W. Breitenbach

Roy W. Breitenbach

Member

Related Legal Practices

Government Compliance and Investigations

Related Industries

Health Care
Facebook
(Twitter)
LinkedIn
Email
Copy Page Link

Contact Us

Harris Beach Murtha Attorneys at Law
  • Contact
  • Offices
  • Privacy Policy
  • Legal Disclaimer
  • Site Map
  • Contact
  • Offices
  • Privacy Policy
  • Legal Disclaimer
  • Site Map
Payment Portal
X-twitter Facebook Linkedin Instagram

Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. © 2025 Harris Beach Murtha Cullina PLLC

TRUSTe
Harris Beach Murtha Attorneys at Law
Back to Top

Insights

No Surprises Act Shouldn’t Stun Physicians in New York State

Capabilities
People
Harris Beach Murtha Attorneys at Law
Legal Alert
April 1, 2022

No Surprises Act Shouldn’t Stun Physicians in New York State

Insight

This week, Crain’s Health Pulse highlighted a lawsuit that I and my colleagues Dan Hallak and Jack Martins commenced earlier this week. We filed the lawsuit on behalf of 18 physician practices and four Empire Plan enrollees in the Supreme Court, Albany County, contending that the New York State Health Insurance program has attempted to sidestep the state’s surprise-billing law, drastically reducing payments for out-of-network services more than 80 percent.

The federal No Surprises Act (NSA) took effect on January 1, 2022 – governing how managed care companies reimburse out-of-network providers and how disputes between health plans and out-of-network providers are resolved. This law is designed to manage patients’ costs for emergency services or health care they receive at an in-network facility, from out-of-network doctors. Federal and state laws have established different benchmarks for determining a “reasonable amount” when insurers and physicians disagree. In this case, the health plan has opted to funnel these surprise-billing disputes through the federal government’s adjudication system, instead of the process outlined in New York state’s surprise billing law.

This lawsuit underscores the importance of understanding key issues. How does the NSA work within the existing New York Surprise Bill Law, and what is the impact on health practices that are chiefly out-of-network, such as anesthesiology, pathology and surgical care? How can practices best serve patients while protecting their business? Join us on Wednesday for our latest webinar on the Federal NSA.

Authors

Roy W. Breitenbach

Member
(516) 880-8378
rbreitenbach@harrisbeachmurtha.com
Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. © 2026 Harris Beach Murtha Cullina PLLC
Content current as of September 5, 2026 5:04 am